Independent · Licensed in PA · NJ · NY · FL
BETTER COVERAGE.
BETTER RATES.
ONE LOCAL AGENCY.
Let Keystone Shield Insurance shop for coverage that fits your needs and budget. Get a fast, free insurance quote today.
- Fast & Free Quotes
- Multiple Insurance Options
- Licensed in PA, NJ, NY & FL
- Personal Service
- No Obligation
Fast · Free · No Obligation
See How Much You Could Save
What do you need insurance for?
By submitting, you agree to be contacted by Keystone Shield Insurance about your insurance inquiry by phone, text, or email. Consent is not a condition of purchase.
As an independent agency, we shop top carriers for you
Coverage Options
Insurance built around your life.
Auto
Auto coverage protects you on every Pennsylvania road. We shop options so you don't overpay for the protection you need.
Get a Free QuoteHome
Your home is likely your biggest investment. We help you protect the structure, your belongings, and your liability.
Get a Free QuoteAuto + Home Bundle
One agency, one point of contact, coverage that works together. Bundling is one of the easiest ways to simplify and potentially save.
Get a Free QuoteRenters
Renters insurance is often more affordable than people expect and protects what your landlord's policy doesn't.
Get a Free QuoteMotorcycle
From weekend cruisers to daily riders, we help you find coverage that fits your bike and budget.
Get a Free QuoteCommercial / Business
Protect your operation, property, employees, and reputation with coverage tailored to your industry.
Get a Free QuoteCommercial Auto
Whether it's one work truck or an entire fleet, we help protect your vehicles, drivers, and cargo.
Get a Free QuoteLife Insurance
The right life insurance gives your family financial security. We'll help you understand your options.
Get a Free QuoteOther
As an independent agency we can help with a wide range of coverage needs. Tell us what you're looking for.
Get a Free QuoteWhy customers choose us
Fast Quotes
Start online in minutes and hear back the same business day.
Licensed in 4 States
Serving clients across Pennsylvania, New Jersey, New York, and Florida.
Multiple Options
As an independent agency, we shop coverage to fit your needs and budget.
Personal Service
Real people who take the time to explain your options — no pressure.
What our customers say
“I had a fantastic experience! I didn't realize this business was new to the area. When I walked in, Gary and the other staff were extremely polite. I came in to renew my vehicle registration, and Gary also helped me find more affordable insurance for my vehicle. I was very impressed with the customer service and will definitely continue to do business here. Thank you, Gary!”
“I had a great experience with Keystone Shield Insurance. From the start, they were professional and genuinely helpful in finding the right coverage for my needs. They took the time to explain everything clearly, making sure I understood my options. What really stood out was their customer service they were quick to answer my questions and made the entire process smooth and stress-free. I’d definitely recommend Keystone Shield Insurance to anyone looking for dependable coverage and a team that actually cares about their clients.”
“I had a great experience here! I worked with Gary, who helped me get insurance set up quickly and made the whole process very straightforward. He was friendly, professional, and made me feel like family. What really stood out was how willing they were to help even when obstacles came up they truly go the extra mile for their customers. Amazing service overall. I’ll definitely be coming back and highly recommend them to anyone looking for reliable, honest help!”
Local insurance, across four states
Keystone Shield Insurance is based in Mount Pocono, Pennsylvania and proudly serves clients throughout Pennsylvania, New Jersey, New York, and Florida. Whether you're comparing car insurance in Monroe County, looking for a cheaper home insurance rate in the Poconos, or need business coverage nearby, we shop multiple carriers to help you find affordable coverage.